Lemon Pie Recipe


lemon-pie-recipe.jpgYes, it’s March 13 and the countdown to Pi Day has begun! While people gather round and sing Pi Day Songs, you can make Aunt Mattie’s Lemon Pie. Aunt Mattie worked for my grandmother’s family, and was known for her pies: chocolate, butterscotch, and lemon. My grandmother once carefully measured and wrote down the ingredients that Aunt Mattie used, giving the recipe shown here. (Hmmm. It looks like this card could well be that original recipe. I am, perhaps, the messiest cook I know.)

Ready to start cooking? Gather your ingredients:


One lemon, sugar (1 cup plus another 1/3 cup for the meringue), flour (2 Tablespoons), salt (a pinch), two eggs, and 1/2 cup of water. Anyone want to guess which store we usually shop at?

Now prepare everything. Grate the lemon


and also squeeze out the juice. You’ll also need to separate the eggs, saving the egg whites for the meringue.

Mix the lemon juice and rind, the cup of sugar, the flour, the egg yolks, the pinch of salt, and the water in a bowl and put them into the top of a double boiler.


You’re supposed to stir until it “holds its form”. So keep stirring and watching.


(And if you’re like me, this is about the time you decide that it’s never going to thicken on its own and you scrap the whole double boiler thing and put it directly over a flame so that it will thicken.)

Eventually, by chemistry or proclamation, it will be done. Put it aside while you make the meringue. Beat two egg white with the remaining 1/3 cup of sugar.


[There’s a lot of white in this picture isn’t there? But it could be worse. Underneath that radiator cover the radiator is Avocado Green. Weren’t the 70s special?]

Keep mixing until the egg whites get stiff. Then pour the lemon filling into a (cooked or bought) pie crust.


Carefully put the meringue on top, making sure that it touches all the edges of the crust because, well, because that’s what my mom told me to be careful of.

Bake it at about 350° for about 15 minutes, checking to make sure that the top doesn’t burn. And it’s done! Enjoy!


Happy Pi Day!

4 Responses to “Lemon Pie Recipe”

  1. razzbuffnik Says:

    Where can I get me one of those pie making mini-monsters?

  2. Ξ Says:

    Good to have around the house, isn’t he? I’m not sure where he originated — it was a birthday present to my son a year or two ago. He seems to really be enjoying his fame, though (and did you notice that he was totally sticking his fingers in the pie in the last shot? I didn’t even realize it until I wondered why the pie had a hole in the meringue.)

  3. Raisa Diamanta Bingei Says:

    Gee thats a good looking pie oh yeah, I wish I could taste it but actually Im from Indonesia!

  4. Kat Says:

    Just made Maddies pie! And its not even pi day!
    Seriously though tis is a really great recipe.
    Thanks for sharing! :p

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: